6G Celicas Forums

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

2 Pages V   1 2 >  
Reply to this topicStart new topic
> celica 3s-ge vs integra gsr, which is the better engine?
post Apr 14, 2004 - 5:55 PM
+Quote Post
H8DC3lica94



Enthusiast
**
Joined Jan 29, '03
From San Diego, CA
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




I am about to begin my quest into swapping the celica. My first thought was to get the 3s-gte like everyone else and laugh at every civic that comes my way. hahahaha. But that would be the easy way out. i want to be able to kill other racers without going turbo. so i was thinking about the 3S-GE. Beams if possible to obtain. i wanna know if this engine has a chance against the GSR engines.


--------------------
Chris Malaqui
Non-running Celica
post Apr 14, 2004 - 6:08 PM
+Quote Post
bonzaisushi

Enthusiast
***
Joined Oct 3, '02
From bonzaisushi@hotmail.com
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




ya it does, but its a more complicated swap... i believe there is 1 personr ight now doing the swap
post Apr 14, 2004 - 7:23 PM
+Quote Post
celicarocker

Enthusiast
*****
Joined Sep 25, '03
From cranston RI
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




is there a reason you want non turbo? if your gonna swap, just go with the 3s-gte... more power, and alot more people to help you along the way....


--------------------
user posted image
post Apr 14, 2004 - 7:28 PM
+Quote Post
Doge



Enthusiast
***
Joined Dec 2, '02
From Portland, Oregon
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




QUOTE (celicarocker @ Apr 14, 2004 - 5:23 PM)
is there a reason you want non turbo? if your gonna swap, just go with the 3s-gte... more power, and alot more people to help you along the way....

ALOOOOOT more people...haha...you can have every problem that you run into solved by asking the geniuses on this site. But with the 3sge, you're not gonna have much help.
post Apr 14, 2004 - 7:39 PM
+Quote Post
Digndoug



Enthusiast
*****
Joined Aug 20, '03
From Annapolis, Md
Currently Offline

Reputation: 5 (100%)




ok, first off, the 3s-ge should be easier then the gte, because first off, you getting rid of the turbo an intercooler piping, an anything else that goes along with the turbo. I dont know about the beams though, an the 3s-ge should be able to beat a gsr, not tear it up or anything, im tyring to set it up now. not the beams though.
post Apr 14, 2004 - 7:44 PM
+Quote Post
H8DC3lica94



Enthusiast
**
Joined Jan 29, '03
From San Diego, CA
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




going turbo does sound great. but having turbo means more maintenace and having to go trough more BS from cops and authorities. blah blah blah. i havent completely ruled out going turbo by the way. i'm just looking for alternate routes. Cali isnt the greatest place to go turbo or even start messing with the car. besides, the thought of having a non-turbo and kicking ass. And to have better times and out run a turboed car. i like that better.


--------------------
Chris Malaqui
Non-running Celica
post Apr 14, 2004 - 7:49 PM
+Quote Post
macavely



Enthusiast
*****
Joined Nov 4, '02
From Hecho en la Republica Dominicana/Living in NJ
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




i been considering the 3sge over the gte simply cuase it's esyier to hide... not many people are going to know that is not the stock engine.. but they see a turbo under the hood it might just not seam right..

i think the ge would be a bit more simpler to swap just cause the lack of the turbo .. but i haven't done either so i can't really tell..


--------------------
post Apr 14, 2004 - 7:54 PM
+Quote Post
LatinKraze



Enthusiast
****
Joined Oct 22, '03
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




I'm have concidered swapping the 3SGE as well. But i dont know shirt about swaps.....so i'm readin up.
post Apr 14, 2004 - 9:13 PM
+Quote Post
JDM7afe

Enthusiast

Joined Mar 3, '04
From Las Vegas
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




I'm considering a swap in another year and a half or so and i would really like to have the BEAMS engine but it sounds like there isnt enough info on the swap so i got to thinking about swapping for a 4a-ge blacktop and turboing it(not sure if anyone has done that or if it is even advisable). it would be cool to have a 6 spd and rev a lil higher and you throw a turbo in the mix! *WOW* i think it would be quick but i have no info... lol my post was basically pointless
Preston
post Apr 14, 2004 - 10:17 PM
+Quote Post
toyotaspeed_90

Enthusiast
**
Joined Jan 22, '04
From bellingham, WA
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




hell... you could run a 3s-ge off a 5s-fe or quite possibly even a 7a-fe ecu
post Apr 15, 2004 - 12:06 AM
+Quote Post
saleeka



Enthusiast
****
Joined Sep 4, '03
From Twin Cities MN
Currently Offline

Reputation: 2 (100%)




i read somewher else on the site not long ago at all that 3s-ge's are really rare- and because of that, pricey. Also, the BEAMS wiring is much more complicated. Evidence of this is the fact that nobody has completed this swap. I tire of those who are like- if you are gunna go that route why not get the 3sgte... the first reason that comes to my mind is that the car is FWD. That and its like excuse me for being different... lol...


--------------------
Car #3: 98 Accord LX- purchased 5/06, totaled 8/06
Car #2: 95 Celica GT- purchased 8/03, current daily driver
Car #1: 01 Focus ZX3- purchased 5/01, sold 8/03
post Apr 15, 2004 - 12:09 AM
+Quote Post
Digndoug



Enthusiast
*****
Joined Aug 20, '03
From Annapolis, Md
Currently Offline

Reputation: 5 (100%)




well, are you all talking about the beams 3s-ge, or the older one? cause i thought the beams was the new one, with like alomst 200hp, what about the older one that produces 180, that shouldnt be nearly as hard...

does any one have the years with the amounts of power? Like i mean a 2nd gen, im gunna guess, is the 180hp, 1992 or somthin? any one wanna help. an pics.. possible.
post Apr 15, 2004 - 12:09 AM
+Quote Post
toyotaspeed_90

Enthusiast
**
Joined Jan 22, '04
From bellingham, WA
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




if you find a non vvt 3sge then it wouldn't be tough on wiring.... probably the same wiring as your 5s-fe
post Apr 15, 2004 - 12:59 AM
+Quote Post
ssnake86

Enthusiast
*
Joined Mar 18, '04
From San Diego
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




how much would the whole swap cost you? engine and everything $6k?
post Apr 15, 2004 - 1:07 AM
+Quote Post
saleeka



Enthusiast
****
Joined Sep 4, '03
From Twin Cities MN
Currently Offline

Reputation: 2 (100%)




QUOTE (Digndoug @ Apr 15, 2004 - 5:09 AM)
well, are you all talking about the beams 3s-ge, or the older one?

both for cost- only the beams has the extra comlicated wiring from my understanding


--------------------
Car #3: 98 Accord LX- purchased 5/06, totaled 8/06
Car #2: 95 Celica GT- purchased 8/03, current daily driver
Car #1: 01 Focus ZX3- purchased 5/01, sold 8/03
post Apr 15, 2004 - 1:28 AM
+Quote Post
97sccelica



Enthusiast
*****
Joined Aug 30, '02
From Anaheim, CA
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




QUOTE (H8DC3lica94 @ Apr 14, 2004 - 4:44 PM)
going turbo does sound great. but having turbo means more maintenace and having to go trough more BS from cops and authorities. blah blah blah. i havent completely ruled out going turbo by the way. i'm just looking for alternate routes. Cali isnt the greatest place to go turbo or even start messing with the car. besides, the thought of having a non-turbo and kicking ass. And to have better times and out run a turboed car. i like that better.

out run what turbo cars?

swapping in a 3sge would put your celica at a little faster than a stock GSR, and probably the same as an ITR

and keeping it NA, there isnt much you can do to the engine to make the car faster(just like every other NA 4 cylinder DOHC engine tuned for as much power and practicality as possible from the factory).

it would most likely max out at low 14's(with out lots of internal work, $$$), that is if you plan on having some sort of interior

it would be faster than stock, no doubt about that, but it wont be that fast compaired to the cars on the market now and it cant be made too much faster while still being NA

and wouldnt you really kick your self in the ass, if you swapped in a 3sge, put the basic bolt ons on the car, only to lose to stock srt-4's or WRX's with intake and exhaust, then decide to turbo the 3sge to get more power when you could have started off with a 3sgte?

im sorry, but no toyota NA 4 cylinder is going to outrun anything more than IHE hondas/acuras(you would be suprised at how many are turboed, or extensively modified)

if you want just a little more power, than go for a 3sge

but from reading what you want, dont expect to get it from a 3sge. power and reliability have an inverse relationship

the more power, the less reliable. if you dont want the hassle of checking the oil once every day or two, or letting the car cool down after a hard run. then the 3sge is for you(allthough stock 3sgte's go to 200k miles with little trouble) and power needs to be sacrificed


--------------------
1994 Celica GT4 WRC Edition
@gt4.wrc on Instagram
post Apr 15, 2004 - 1:47 AM
+Quote Post
Magic



Enthusiast
****
Joined Mar 30, '03
From Cyprus
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




rolleyes.gif ......If you want to go with non-turbo engine you should invest more and the gain will not be fair,but if you go for the 3S-GTE its worth it.
If i was at your place my choice will be 3S-GE Beams(VVTI),GSRs its not problem with this engine and few upgrades. tongue.gif tongue.gif
post Apr 15, 2004 - 2:01 AM
+Quote Post
Chrobis



Enthusiast
****
Joined Apr 15, '03
From San Jose, CA, USA
Currently Offline

Reputation: 1 (100%)




all I have to say is dont be cool trying to be different... and if you think its hard finding parts for a 5s-fe, try getting stuff for a 3s-ge, and even harder for a beams 3s-ge considering it was made for all of 2 years... here in the US there is an abundance of aftermarket parts for a st185 3s-gte. If you get a 3s-ge, you will probably never be able to make it anymore then it is when you put it in the car.
post Apr 15, 2004 - 6:42 AM
+Quote Post
neoklis



Enthusiast
***
Joined Oct 24, '03
From Cyprus
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




Personally i think the 3SGE is a waste of time and money. Reasons:
1. 3SGE maxes out at 170ish bhp. Afriend of mine has invested a lot and has it now at 197bhp
2. 3SGE beams is at a bout 200bhp. But there aren't alot of things you could do with that for more power. Some mods (induction kits) that exist are very pricey without that much gain.

So the best solution i have heard so far is to use the ST205 engine block but go with a ST185 turbo setup like Neverstop is planning to do.
post Apr 15, 2004 - 3:07 PM
+Quote Post
toyotaspeed_90

Enthusiast
**
Joined Jan 22, '04
From bellingham, WA
Currently Offline

Reputation: 0 (0%)




n/a 4 cylinders can run faster than mid to low 14's...... just a simple h22 swap into a civic h/b can run a mid 13....... and there was an n/a b20b integra up the street (sold it) that ran 12's (has videos)..... you can build n/a, just depends on the money you want to spend

but if just 1/4 mile is your goal why? just do something easier & cheaper

2 Pages V   1 2 >
Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 



Lo-Fi Version Time is now: April 24th, 2025 - 6:23 AM