Lightweight Batteries, Comprehensive Information to help your decision |
Lightweight Batteries, Comprehensive Information to help your decision |
Feb 9, 2012 - 5:59 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Dec 22, '06 From Columbia, MD Currently Offline Reputation: 13 (100%) |
Inform me of any mistakes!
Lightweight AGM/GEL batteries are a great alternative and are sometimes priced nearly the same as regular Lead Acid batteries Just to touch on a few of the basics before we begin: Cold Cranking Amps: CCA is critical for good cranking ability. It's the number of amps a battery can support for 30 seconds at a temperature of 0 degrees F until the battery voltage drops to unusable levels. A 12V battery with a rating of 600 CCA means the battery will provide 600 amps for 30 seconds at 0 degrees before the voltage falls to 7.20 V (six cells). In general, with CCA, the higher the number the better. HOWEVER, if you live in a cold climate, the CCA rating should be an important consideration in choosing a battery. Conversely, if you live in a high heat climate, you don't need as much CCA. Battery Types: AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) - i.e. Braille and Optima Gel Cell - i.e. Oddessy A couple differences between Gel and AGM Gel batteries tend to lose power faster than AGM batteries in temperatures below 32°F. AGM batteries, on the other hand, excel in high current and high power applications as well as extremely cold environments. Gel batteries typically have a higher price point, shorter life span and less size compatibility than their AGM counterparts. Benefits of Lightweight Sealed Batteries - can be mounted and used in almost any position (versus conventional batteries, which must remain upright) - are sealed and non-spillable - maintenance-free - no fume emissions (trace) - more resistant to vibration Here is a detailed list of aftermarket batteries that may or may not fit your applications. If you want to get extreme, some of the lightweight batteries like Oddessy, Deka, Braille, etc are great. Although rugged they tend to lack the reliability of a large lead acid battery. Take this into consideration. Especially if your in a colder climate. As far as I know - All the CCA for the manufacturers is done at 0F, and the CA at 32F, all this info is off the manufacturers websites. If you want 100% factory reliability even at 0F you want to be shopping around for something that will have at least 360CCA. For those of you where the weather gets in the negative digits (F) you will want something that has a CCA > 360 at 0F If your car isnt on an extreme diet or you are trying to allocate space for other go-fast bits just stick with a regular lead acid store bought battery READ THIS: Deka Batteries are more than likely to be Deka ETX rebadged -- Their advertised CCA IS PROBABLY NOT PERFORMED AT 0F. The Deka brand are the exact same battery as the Braille, just MUCH CHEAPER. Just different labeling. Braille operates under Deka. (as of 2012) AVG Weight of a regular replacement battery is around 37lbs. By Brand: Braille: Braille B3121 ----------CCA: 550 ---- weight: 21lb ---------------- CA: 742 Braille B2015 ----------CCA: 425 ---- weight: 15lb ---------------- CA: 574 Braille B14115 ---------CCA: 360 ---- weight: 11lb,8oz ------------ CA: 486 Braille B106 -----------CCA: 210 ---- weight: 6lb,6oz ------------- CA: 283 The Braille B2317 and B2317R are meant to be combined (One Positively Charged the other Negative) To be able to run 24v Information pertaining to the conditions the Braille batteries where tested in where not listed, Therefore the u nusually high CCA kind of disproves the statement that DEKA and Braille are not similar but I am working on more info on that. Deka: Deka ETX30 -----------CCA: 370 ---- weight: 21.7lb Deka ETX20 -----------CCA: 270 ---- weight: 15.5lb Deka ETX18 -----------CCA: 300 ---- weight: 18lb Deka ETX16 -----------CCA: 275 ---- weight: 17lb Deka ETX14 -----------CCA: 200 ---- weight: 12lb Deka ETX12 -----------CCA: 180 ---- weight: 9.4lb Deka ETX9 -----------CCA: 120 ---- weight: 6.3lb Odyssey: Odyssey PC680 --------CCA: 220 --- weight: 15lb / 16lb For MJT* Odyssey PC925/MJT ---CCA: 380 --- weight: 24lb / 26lb For MJT* Optima: Optima 34&34R --------CCA 800 -----weight: 37.9lb --------------- CA: 1000 (34R has reversed terminals) Optima 37/78 ----------CCA 800 ---- weight: 38.8lb --------------- CA: 1000 Optima 75/25 ----------CCA 720 ---- weight: 33.1lb --------------- CA: 910 Optima 25&35 ---------CCA 720 ----- weight: 31.7lb --------------- CA: 910 Duralast: Duralast 8AMU1R ------CCA: 330 ---- weight: 20lb AGM Duracell Ultra SLIU1RT ------CCA:370 ---- weight: 24lbs Marathon: Marathon MAR-8AMU1R-CCA: 320 ---- weight: 25lb By CCA: Optima 34&34R --------CCA 800 -----weight: 37.9lb -------------- CA: 1000 Optima 37/78 ----------CCA 800 ---- weight: 38.8lb -------------- CA: 1000 Optima 75/25 ----------CCA 720 ---- weight: 33.1lb -------------- CA: 910 Optima 25&35 ---------CCA 720 ----- weight: 31.7lb -------------- CA: 910 Braille B3121 ----------CCA: 550 ---- weight: 21lb ---------------- CA: 742 Westco Miata ---------CCA: 475 ---- weight: 25lb Braille B2015 ----------CCA: 425 ---- weight: 15lb ---------------- CA: 574 Odyssey PC925/MJT ---CCA: 380 ---- weight: 24lb / 26lb For MJT* Deka ETX30 -----------CCA: 370 ---- weight: 21.7lb Duracell Ultra SLIU1RT AGM ------CCA:370 ---- weight: 24lbs Braille B14115 ---------CCA: 360 ---- weight: 11lb,8oz ------------ CA: 486 Duralast 8AMU1R ------CCA: 330 ---- weight: 20lb Marathon MAR-8AMU1R-CCA: 320 ---- weight: 25lb Deka ETX18 -----------CCA: 300 ---- weight: 18lb Deka ETX16 -----------CCA: 275 ---- weight: 17lb Deka ETX20 -----------CCA: 270 ---- weight: 15.5lb Odyssey PC680 --------CCA: 220 ---- weight: 15lb / 16lb For MJT* Braille B106 -----------CCA: 210 ---- weight: 6lb,6oz ------------- CA: 283 Deka ETX14 -----------CCA: 200 ---- weight: 12lb Deka ETX12 -----------CCA: 180 ---- weight: 9.4lb Deka ETX9 -----------CCA: 120 ---- weight: 6.3lb By Weight: Optima 37/78 ----------CCA 800 ---- weight: 38.8lb --------------- CA: 1000 Optima 34&34R --------CCA 800 -----weight: 37.9lb --------------- CA: 1000 Optima 75/25 ----------CCA 720 ---- weight: 33.1lb --------------- CA: 910 Optima 25&35 ---------CCA 720 ----- weight: 31.7lb --------------- CA: 910 Westco Miata ---------CCA: 475 ---- weight: 25lb Marathon MAR-8AMU1R-CCA: 320 ---- weight: 25lb AGM Duracell Ultra SLIU1RT ------CCA:370 ---- weight: 24lbs Odyssey PC925/MJT ---CCA: 380 --- weight: 24lb / 26lb For MJT* Deka ETX30 -----------CCA: 370 ---- weight: 21.7lb Braille B3121 ----------CCA: 550 ---- weight: 21lb ---------------- CA: 742 Duralast 8AMU1R ------CCA: 330 ---- weight: 20lb Braille B14115 ---------CCA: 360 ---- weight: 11lb,8oz ------------ CA: 486 Deka ETX18 -----------CCA: 300 ---- weight: 18lb Deka ETX16 -----------CCA: 275 ---- weight: 17lb Deka ETX20 -----------CCA: 270 ---- weight: 15.5lb Odyssey PC680 --------CCA: 220 --- weight: 15lb / 16lb For MJT* Braille B2015 ----------CCA: 425 ---- weight: 15lb ---------------- CA: 574 Deka ETX14 -----------CCA: 200 ---- weight: 12lb Deka ETX12 -----------CCA: 180 ---- weight: 9.4lb Braille B106 -----------CCA: 210 ---- weight: 6lb,6oz ------------- CA: 283 Deka ETX9 -----------CCA: 120 ---- weight: 6.3lb *MJT: Metal Jacket + Terminals (MJT is applied to protect plastic case for extreme high heat conditions) Warranty Information: In my opinion this is a critical area when deciding which battery to go with. I will add more information as I get it. Marathon MAR-8AMU1R (1Year Warranty) Westco 12V31M (4 Year Warranty) Duralast 8AMU1R (8Year Warranty - apparently WAS avaible at autozone) More info: DEKA: Come with M6 Thread on terminals - you will need adapter to SAE automotive Terminals. Rebadged as BigCrank, Braille and other brands // BigCrank has a cheap price. This post has been edited by Tigawoods: Mar 8, 2016 - 7:12 AM -------------------- 1995 GT::::Diffusing the Situation エキサイティングカーレーシングチーム! march 2010 COTM : 6GC feature 2014 : january 2015-2016-2018 COTM |
Feb 10, 2012 - 3:25 AM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Feb 24, '07 From Oahu, Hawaii Currently Offline Reputation: 23 (100%) |
What about using other car batteries in our cars, especially if you're doing a batt relocation?
The Honda Half-Brick group 51r and 51??? Pretty light and should do the job. Optima Yel51 is pretty light already. But then again it is also still a Half-brick. I'll look into some catalogs at work for some batteries -------------------- I don't normally drive fast, but when I do its on a curvy section of this island
|
Feb 10, 2012 - 8:42 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Dec 22, '06 From Columbia, MD Currently Offline Reputation: 13 (100%) |
yeah post up what you come up with
-------------------- 1995 GT::::Diffusing the Situation エキサイティングカーレーシングチーム! march 2010 COTM : 6GC feature 2014 : january 2015-2016-2018 COTM |
Feb 11, 2012 - 12:51 AM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Apr 24, '08 From Orange County, CA Currently Offline Reputation: 33 (100%) |
since you do autocross, I'd suggest moving the light weight battery to the passenger side floor (to take the wheel off the front of the car, thus creating less understeer) well I don't have to spoon feed you this info, your probably know more than I do
-------------------- Group buy to replicate Narrow E series transaxle parts
http://www.6gc.net/forums/index.php?showto...p;#entry1107514 |
Feb 11, 2012 - 4:01 AM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Feb 24, '07 From Oahu, Hawaii Currently Offline Reputation: 23 (100%) |
dont forget, half your job is to remind me about this.........
-------------------- I don't normally drive fast, but when I do its on a curvy section of this island
|
Feb 12, 2012 - 2:52 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Aug 11, '08 From London Currently Offline Reputation: 7 (100%) |
sooooo size is most important for me which is why I'm using a caterham banner battery.
Which one of these are of a similar size or even smaller yet has a good crank and strong load because I know my battery isn't that good on load in these cold weather temps. |
Feb 13, 2012 - 9:39 AM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Dec 22, '06 From Columbia, MD Currently Offline Reputation: 13 (100%) |
since you do autocross, I'd suggest moving the light weight battery to the passenger side floor (to take the wheel off the front of the car, thus creating less understeer) well I don't have to spoon feed you this info, your probably know more than I do Eventually I would like to do that. Either the passenger area or the rear passenger seat area. dont forget, half your job is to remind me about this......... You are a big boy! Im not holding you're hand ANYMORE!!! sooooo size is most important for me which is why I'm using a caterham banner battery. Which one of these are of a similar size or even smaller yet has a good crank and strong load because I know my battery isn't that good on load in these cold weather temps. You can grab the model number listed and search for it. The Caterham is a medium sized battery, with only 300CCA. For a reliable long lasting lightweight battery you will have to look at the ones in the 21LB range Any lighter and you are looking at batteries that are used for a dedicated weekend track car. I am still looking into the reliability of the Braille batteries and their 11lb 360cca battery. This post has been edited by Tigawoods: Feb 13, 2012 - 9:39 AM -------------------- 1995 GT::::Diffusing the Situation エキサイティングカーレーシングチーム! march 2010 COTM : 6GC feature 2014 : january 2015-2016-2018 COTM |
Feb 13, 2012 - 4:05 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Aug 11, '08 From London Currently Offline Reputation: 7 (100%) |
|
Feb 13, 2012 - 5:01 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Apr 24, '08 From Orange County, CA Currently Offline Reputation: 33 (100%) |
hehe I'm so glad our so cal weather (controlled by the government) is nice all year around!! It gets 45-100 degree all year around. So even the smallest battery have enough crank amps to fire up the celi on a winter day
-------------------- Group buy to replicate Narrow E series transaxle parts
http://www.6gc.net/forums/index.php?showto...p;#entry1107514 |
Feb 13, 2012 - 5:24 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Dec 22, '06 From Columbia, MD Currently Offline Reputation: 13 (100%) |
The Caterham is a medium sized battery, with only 300CCA. Really? I always thought it was the smallest as I couldn't find any battery with enough cranking power smaller than the caterham banner battery. The Braille may have a lighter one with more CCA but I still havent confirmed it yet. hehe I'm so glad our so cal weather (controlled by the government) is nice all year around!! It gets 45-100 degree all year around. So even the smallest battery have enough crank amps to fire up the celi on a winter day DAMN YOU!! -------------------- 1995 GT::::Diffusing the Situation エキサイティングカーレーシングチーム! march 2010 COTM : 6GC feature 2014 : january 2015-2016-2018 COTM |
Feb 14, 2012 - 9:05 AM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Aug 11, '08 From London Currently Offline Reputation: 7 (100%) |
I'll try and lok it up Tigs but pls do let me know if you find out first.
Another option I've been thinking is if one of these can fit within the arm rest storage. Doesn't matter if its taller cos I can sink it in deeper. |
Feb 14, 2012 - 8:39 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Mar 11, '06 From Way South Chicago Currently Offline Reputation: 0 (0%) |
http://www.summitracing.com/parts/DUI-5575B/
I'm thinking about one of those, but I don't know how well they do with sitting around for periods of time. -------------------- |
Mar 1, 2012 - 5:02 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Apr 28, '09 From Auburn, AL Currently Offline Reputation: 0 (0%) |
Consider a Dry cell battery. They are more expensive per Amp hour, but are perfect for a lightweight, high output application if you dont mind payin a bit extra
Shuriken BT60 (about $160 shipped)has a CA rating of 1500 and weighs 36.8 lbs. Shuriken BT35 (about $120 shipped) has a CA rating of 950 and weighs 25.5 lbs. Shuriken BT20 (about $79 shipped)has a CA rating of 850 and weighs only 14 lbs. I havent seen the CCA rating for these, but i believe dry cells are less sensitive to temperature. I am not 100% sure about that though |
Mar 2, 2012 - 10:15 AM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Jun 18, '09 From Orlando Currently Offline Reputation: 8 (100%) |
^ That's hella cheap, and 14 pounds. I think I may have found my next battery, assuming it can deal with my temperature range. I'm in the same conditions as Bonzai.
-------------------- '97 ST \ Eibach \ KYB \ Kenwood \ Alpine \ Cusco \ OEM+ [sold 10/18]
'93 MX-5 LE |
Mar 2, 2012 - 1:07 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Apr 24, '08 From Orange County, CA Currently Offline Reputation: 33 (100%) |
^ That's hella cheap, and 14 pounds. I think I may have found my next battery, assuming it can deal with my temperature range. I'm in the same conditions as Bonzai. yea seems to be a real good battery! http://www.sonicelectronix.com/reviews.php?product_id=17907 only complaint i've seen is that the terminals aren't the greatest... but nonetheless cheap battery -------------------- Group buy to replicate Narrow E series transaxle parts
http://www.6gc.net/forums/index.php?showto...p;#entry1107514 |
Mar 3, 2012 - 4:29 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Mar 11, '06 From Way South Chicago Currently Offline Reputation: 0 (0%) |
Around 650 CCA on that BT20. Rough rule of thumb is to divide CA by 1.25 and round down a little. Not bad for a little battery, I may just roll with that then. I have some threaded battery post terminals already.
-------------------- |
Mar 3, 2012 - 9:03 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Apr 28, '09 From Auburn, AL Currently Offline Reputation: 0 (0%) |
DISCLAIMER
The [20] is for the amp hours. That being said, be extra vigilant about leavin those interior lights on 8) |
Mar 3, 2012 - 9:31 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Mar 11, '06 From Way South Chicago Currently Offline Reputation: 0 (0%) |
All LED interior lighting here.
-------------------- |
Jan 3, 2013 - 9:03 AM |
|
Enthusiast Joined Dec 22, '06 From Columbia, MD Currently Offline Reputation: 13 (100%) |
finally settled on one and got a Braille B2105 15lb battery
along with it I got a Battery Tender Plus to maintain the batteries charge while it sits in the garage over the next few months. Im curious to see how the battery holds up come the summertime when I start driving the car -------------------- 1995 GT::::Diffusing the Situation エキサイティングカーレーシングチーム! march 2010 COTM : 6GC feature 2014 : january 2015-2016-2018 COTM |
Jan 3, 2013 - 12:54 PM |
|
Enthusiast Joined May 22, '03 From NOVA Currently Offline Reputation: 16 (100%) |
why you no relocate?
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: November 23rd, 2024 - 6:34 AM |